F10 520i Turbo or F30 328i?

  • Click here to become an Official Member of BMW Club Malaysia Download Form

kevcrave

Club Guest
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
20
Points
0
Hi guys and sifu sifu here. Its been awhile since my E93 serving me and im planning to get a used F10 520i or F30 328i.
Im considering practicality and also running cost. I dont wish to visit workshop too often :motz:

F10 comes in 1st place but im just afraid of the running cost

What is your thought?
 
both also using same engine, so maintenance should be the same. The general consensus is that the f30 has better handling whereas the f10 is more for comfort. Should also consider the 528i.
 
F10. Different class altogether. I'm driving F30 328i now, 95% of the time on Comfort settings but F10 definitely more comfortable to me. One big reason is that it's quieter. My F30 isn't quiet at highway speeds. Sporty, yes; luxuriously comfortable, no. But F10, I think much better.
 
For me.....I recommend the F10. That said, go test the 520i vs the 520d vs the 528i and decide.

Choose wisely !
 
I think it really depends what you want, whether a small sedan or something spacious for the family? If you drive alone most of the time and performance is what you want then obviously the F30. If you're a family man that wants to bring everyone comfortably then the F10.

If you're buying recond or used, anything could potentially fail especially when the car is 4-5 years old. Otherwise consider the pre-reg as they are getting real cheap these days. 5 years warranty helps.
 
kavia11 said:
can i ask..how about the f30 330e vs the f10 520i m sport?
Different category wor! May be to ask what are the specific features you are looking at?
 
jnc621 said:
Different category wor! May be to ask what are the specific features you are looking at?
yeah bro...different category and specs....
well i am looking at good performance, comfortable and relatively good space for a family of 2 adults with 2 kids...
of course..the question is the price difference....i posted it in a different thread earlier..330e for 238k and 520i for 275k...
 
kavia11 said:
yeah bro...different category and specs....
well i am looking at good performance, comfortable and relatively good space for a family of 2 adults with 2 kids...
of course..the question is the price difference....i posted it in a different thread earlier..330e for 238k and 520i for 275k...
Hi,
I choose 330e because of iPerformance (PHEV) at least new technology (I dare to try even some people say wait for it to mature first) which perfectly suit for city drive with hybrid, somemore is plug-in which is different to others Japan hybrid car. The combination of eDrive (3 selection) + Eco pro, Comfort, Sport, Sport+. It is really fun to drive. This car is loaded more specs among the 3 series which we really like. Sunroof, Headup display. Of course, no M sport.

In terms of performance, the statistic shown that 330e faster than 520i because of the combination of power output even the weight is heavier (hybrid battery). In reality, perhaps you won't feel much different. So it is no concern for you.

Spaces, 520i is your choice. The E-segment is larger. Personally, I didn't get complain from my family (2 adults) who sit at the back :) Again, the drawback of hybrid battery will occupy the boot space, therefore smaller. If you are travelling more often with luggages then 520i.

Price correction, 330e should be RM248k. If you came across RM238k let me know.

On more condition make your decision better, if you are not convenient to charge your car daily, then 520i. I am not saying the 330e must charge from power outlet. It can be charged when driving, however you might not utilise the electric power in a more efficiency way.
 
jnc621 said:
Hi,
I choose 330e because of iPerformance (PHEV) at least new technology (I dare to try even some people say wait for it to mature first) which perfectly suit for city drive with hybrid, somemore is plug-in which is different to others Japan hybrid car. The combination of eDrive (3 selection) + Eco pro, Comfort, Sport, Sport+. It is really fun to drive. This car is loaded more specs among the 3 series which we really like. Sunroof, Headup display. Of course, no M sport.

In terms of performance, the statistic shown that 330e faster than 520i because of the combination of power output even the weight is heavier (hybrid battery). In reality, perhaps you won't feel much different. So it is no concern for you.

Spaces, 520i is your choice. The E-segment is larger. Personally, I didn't get complain from my family (2 adults) who sit at the back :) Again, the drawback of hybrid battery will occupy the boot space, therefore smaller. If you are travelling more often with luggages then 520i.

Price correction, 330e should be RM248k. If you came across RM238k let me know.

On more condition make your decision better, if you are not convenient to charge your car daily, then 520i. I am not saying the 330e must charge from power outlet. It can be charged when driving, however you might not utilise the electric power in a more efficiency way.
yup...the 330e is excellent..loved it and wanted to book it till I get the deal on the 520i...main reason is because for a 30k more i get a 5 series and that adaptive dampers with the space is just too good to resist..i did enjoyed the drive on 330e..it has the power...and the specs is just too good...love the heads up display...

space wise yes bro..330e is good enough..the boot space is a slight issue..i have two kids..both need the stroller for now..so that's like a requirement...i dont travel outstation much..so that is no biggie..

the price is 248k..the price i stated 238k is with 10k discount given...for brand new car..with tint and regal coating..
 
Top Bottom