Fifth Gear's Review on 1 series
Intended to be a rival to the Audi A3, the 1 Series offers buyers exactly the same core BMW values as they will find in the rest of the range, including the fabled 50:50 weight distribution and rear-wheel drive.
Plus, of course, controversial design. In terms of looks this is probably the least successful of the recent era BMWs, with the 1's gawky concave flanks and awkward hatchback rear making it look like it's trying far too hard. Once inside the cabin the design improves, with the dashboard, instruments and switchgear all being similar to those of the 3 Series. But despite having a reasonable amount of room in the front, the rear seats are disastrously cramped, to the extent the 1 is more of a two-plus-two than a proper four-seater. Boot capacity is limited too.
This poor interior packaging comes as a result of the 1 Series' rear-wheel drive layout, which results in a predictably strong driving experience. If you're coming to this segment looking for dynamic purity above anything else then it still makes a strong case for itself, with brilliant roadholding and impressively neutral cornering.
Engine choice is pretty comprehensive, with four petrol motors and two diesels to pick between. Of the petrols, the basic 116i and 118i feel slightly underpowered, the 120i is decently rapid and the 130i is positively fast. But the diesels still make most sense, especially the brawny, refined and economical 156 bhp 120d.
We like:
1) Handling.
2) Muscular 120d diesel engine.
3) that BMW badge.
We don't like:
1) Awkward looks.
2) Cramped rear seats and small boot.
3) Expensive for what you get.
Best and worst:
Most fun: 120d M Sport
Most sensible: 118d ES
Worst: 116i
Breakdown
Styling
2 stars
Only a mother could love the 1's strange combination of conflicting design themes.
Handling
4 stars
Rear wheel drive brings excellent handling with it - loads of grip and pleasantly neutral cornering behaviour.
Comfort
3 stars
Sometimes choppy ride quality detracts from refinement, while rear seat passengers will complain about the lack of legroom.
Quality + reliability
4 stars
A quality item, although some of the switchgear feels a little bit cheap and plasticky.
Performance
3 stars
The basic 116i, 118i and 118d all lack much in the way of urge - and the 130i looks very expensive for what you get. 120d is the best all-rounder.
Roominess
2 stars
Borderline unacceptable for a car trying to compete in this segment. Rear seats are very cramped and the boot is small.
Running costs
4 stars
Respectable thanks to decent fuel economy and low depreciation, plus the option of fixed-price servicing.
Value for money
3 stars
The cheapest way to get yourself behind the BMW roundel, but poor standard equipment (the base models don't even get aircon) means it looks expensive for what you get.
Stereo / Sat nav
3 stars
Standard stereo offers decent quality, although you have to pay extra for steering wheel remote controls. Satnav is an expensive option considering relatively simple system you get.
Environment
3 stars
One of the greenest executive-badged cars, with the 118d and 120d diesels putting out impressively low CO2 figures.