ya geoff,
I'm not test many 318 just 7 car only last month,
most that I test is 328: 8 from motor trade + 14 from newspaper + 2 usedcar
total all bmw that i have test is arround 38 cars including 7: my kazen and unkel bimmer,
then mercedes: 4 pcs only.
318 is still uDM, it has cool handling and cool speed.
the best 318 I try is 318i 1.9L (E46) coupe, cool corner, top speed at 200+km/h quiet stable ( due to lightweight engine+ resonance = little bit goyang at top speed.
the good one I found (but not remember from where, need check my list..)
with great condition, the owner want 57K E36 318 1998, but 318 (my opinion) drink petrol, under power (yes), from start: when the car start to move I feel slow then I put more on throttle paddle equal kuat minyak. I think for chassis like E36 the ideal engine is around 2.5L or above. bmw put 1.8L maybe for market target etc...
my opinion:
E36 318 : cool for run (maintenance side not really know)
E46 318 coupe: wow!!.. but still cannot beat E36 328!
E36 325 : i'm very bad: never really test it yet to max (officially)
E36 328 : cool to run and fun to drive
(no test drive/ be passenger only)
E46 M3 (my boss car) : incredible power and style (maintenance=matilaaa)
M6 (my boss car) : uncomparable power, king of the road (maintenance+FC=matilaaa)
328 is very great & ideal machine for me.
318 feel like Perdana V6 (I found a good one)
_______________________________________________________
one more thing!!
if possible don't buy bmw at used car dealer!
they will try to do everything to sell the car.
they put timber dust and mix it with oil engine to make the engine smooth like silk !! but after used it then come trouble (my friend be a victim for this trick)
kind Regards
ZUL