My 318i rattling/vibrate when I put on the D or R gear. I will be fine if it's on Neutral. It will also rattle if I switch off the Aircon completely. What could be the problem? For your info, I have sent the car for service recently at AB and point out the problems to the mechanic. They had replaced Crankshaft Oil Seal, Oil Pan Gasket, Upper Timing Case Cover Gasket. I was OK when I took it back after service. After about 1 week it starts to rattle again, but it seems not as much as before. But, the thing is...... it still rattling
. Can someone please advise?